Thank you very much hon Emam Shaik, I will certainly look up what has happened since 2006, not having been a member of the House or the Cabinet at the time, but I will be happy to look up and reply directly to the hon member on the matter. If I use the time though briefly, just to comment on the retail sector marketing inquiry, that hon Emam Shaik referred to. There was investigation that Competition Authorities conducted, they looked at two areas. The first was shopping malls and the second one related to retail in townships. The report was recently released, it makes for very, very interesting reading, because it documents a range of practices in both